
But a lack of originality, while certainly not a good thing, isn't necessarily bad. Under the right circumstances, a director could make any film work. And while there is no denying that Guillmero del Toro is a talented man, he simply didn't bring enough to the director's chair to make those clichés disappear. In fact, characters practically announce the clichés to the audience without the slightest bit of irony or even a hint of self awareness. Whether it be virtually every character remarking that Charlie Hunnam's Raleigh is a loose cannon or Charlie Day screaming exposition to the audience, the screenplay for this film is about as subtle as a robot flying through a city.
And while the action is certainly visually stunning, I just wasn't as impressed as the 71% of critics and legions of fans were. Robots fighting monsters certainly sounds exciting, and their are moments that pack quite a punch in terms of the "wow" factor. I can admire the way del Toro staged some of the scenes- unlike so many films in the age of shaky cam and quick editing, Pacific Rim's action scenes are easy to follow and constantly remind you of how big the creatures at war are. But action scenes, like comedies, are subjective- what works for one person might not work for another. I could watch Arnold Schwarzenegger face off against Robert Patrick all day, and sit wide eyed in amazement as Neo takes tries to rescue Morpheus with the most badass helicopter in cinema history. But, other people could watch those same scenes and remain unimpressed. Well, for every moment that left me impressed in Pacific Rim there were two that left me unmoved, and there wasn't a single moment that left me bowled over with excitement. Who knows, maybe the ten year old within was taking a nap. After all, I saw the film late at night.
If anything about this film deserves to be praised, it's the cast. Filled with actors that are on the cusp of breaking into mainstream movies, everyone in Pacific Rim radiates with screen presence. Charlie Hunnam is an excellent leading man who perfectly balances his cocky attitude with his immense likability. He's not given the best material to work with, but he makes the most out of it. Idris Elba also commands the screen, while never soaring over the top. I hope MGM takes note and offers him the role of James Bond once Craig fulfills his contract- that would be an example of fan casting that really works. And, while his character's sole purpose is to (loudly) explain plot devices and make the deus ex machina of an ending a bit easier to swallow, Charlie Day is excellent as a quirky scientist with a unique perspective on the dangerous monsters. I haven't watched much of "It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia" but Day's work in Horrible Bosses was exceptional and I have a feeling that he could bring a lot to the table if he's ever given a starring role. His scenes with Ron Perlman are the highlight of the film- in fact, I'd much rather see a film about the two of them than I would any other character in the film.
Many champions of Pacific Rim are calling for Hollywood to take note of Pacific Rim's perceived originality. While I have a problem with calling this film "original", I do hope producers notice one major distinguishing factor in the film: its diversity. I try not to get political in my reviews but Pacific Rim is a rare action film with a cast made up of numerous different cultures and a women at the center of the action who can more than hold her own in a fight. While the film does (unfortunately) feature a few too many clichés, it's refreshing to see a movie that doesn't have a whitewashed cast of manly men saving the day. Rinko Kikuchi's Mako Mori joins the ranks of Black Widow and Hathaway's Catwoman as a badass action heroine and a positive role model for female viewers in a summer dominated by men in tights. If anything good comes out of Pacific Rim it will (hopefully) be that some action films will start having a female star at its center.
I've seen a number of headlines over the course of the weekend saying something to the effect of "Pacific Rim's box office performance is why we can't have nice things." But... is it? Pacific Rim may not be a brand of action figures or a comic book series, and I commend del Toro for at least attempting to bring a new brand of heroes to the screen. But the film is hardly original. There have been many films like it in the past, and there will be many more films like it in the future. And when given the option, I'd much rather see the films Pacific Rim borrowed plot points from than sit through this movie again. I have no problem with some people enjoying it. Hell, I really liked Man of Steel and audiences were practically lining up with their pitch forks and torches to tear it down. If someone found some sort of nostalgic joy in the film, then good for them. But, I did not.
OVERALL GRADE: C-
Follow Me on Twitter
Follow Me on Letterboxd